Mountain bike
*Vultures Knob>>>Recumbent Bike

Which is better on the knees, a recumbent bike or stepper?


I have had a knee problem for more than 30 years from a car accident. . Which would be easier on my joints and help me lose weight, a recumbent bike to one of those steppers?

Recumbent bikes are better for your knees. I find steppers are too high of an impact for my bad knee; I get on the stepper machine and a few minutes later I am almost crying from the knee pain. I find, however, that rowing, biking, and even light running do not cause pain in my knee. I suggest you go to a good fitness equipment store and try the machines before you purchase one. This will allow you to know how your knee will react to the repetitive movement.

the bike- not only is it working out your legs, but also other parts of your body. the stepper would put a lot of impact on your knees causing the unneccessary, stenous pain.

A bike since you wont have the stress added as you would with a stepper. Once you lose the weight then you can do other things as hiking and things so you dont have all the weight on the knees. Good luck!

deffinatly the bike because every step you would take would put pressure on your knees.

I think a Stepper would give you less problem because no matter what bike it is, your legs & knees are still moving.

Tags
Sport Bike Street Bike Exercise Bike Stationary Bike Recumbent Bike Bmx Bike Kids Bike Schwinn Bike Cruiser Bike Road Bike
Related information
  • How much truth is there to what this trainer is saying?

    45 minutes is a bit extreme for cardio, at most you should be doing about 15 minutes treadmill, and the same again for rowing machine and cross-trainer, (which also tones), though 10 minutes on eac...

  • What's the ideal distance between pedals (17 cm) and the bike seat?

    With the rider seated and the pedals centered under the ball of the feet and the ankles in a neutral position, the knee should be bent slightly: 10-15 degrees. This distance varies according to ins...

  • What type of exercise is ok when pregnant?

    power-walking is good when pregnant, and there are special classes for pregnant women in yoga and step aerobics and water aerobics. Arm exercises would be fine, but crunches and squats are not idea...

  • Recumbent bike building leg muscle!!?

    You are not going to develop strength by biking. You are not getting full range of motion which is necessary to build the actions necessary to jump.

    ...
  • I bought a used Cardiomax 580 recumbent exerercise bike, but it didn't have the owner's manual with it...

    Try visiting the manufacturer's website. If they don't have the manual available online, contact them and ask them to send you a copy.

    ...
  • Which bike is best post ACL reconstruction? Recumbent or Stationary?

    since u were active before ur injury u should be fine with the regular stationary bike... although either bike would produce the same effect.... recumbent bikes are usually used if u have back...

  • Recumbent bikes?

    Your question is obviously vague so I would like to address one type of recumbent: the high-racer recumbent. Some pros and cons are listed below. As in all things, some of these items are subjectiv...

  • Honestly, how difficult are recumbent bicycles to learn?

    No, not hard, just different. I have a Cycle Genius (Falcon) The biggest problem is you want to oversteer when starting. Just set back and relax. They do not climb hills as well as a regular b...

  •  

    Bike Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster